2011年4月4日 星期一

What is Kung Fu, really?


A disappointing discovery

I came across a Kung Fu instructor's YouTube account while browsing the Internet. He had sparring and form videos posted. But what caught my attention wasn't the videos, it was his comments:
Few people in traditional kong-fu willing to recognize the truth that they don't know how to fight and that is why real kong fu is lost and be humiliated by other styles. If you do practice kong fu, then you have to do sparring, you have to use all your strength and exhaust yourself to learn the limits of your system and your own body and mind. There is no way around if you do want be a real master.
and
I am so tired of watching WuShu, it's okay if a dancing style wants to adopt some martial art moves but it is ridiculous for a dancing style to call itself a martial art. Not even mention those crazy shouting and meaningless hand waving moves.
As a passionate student of martial arts, I read this and was disappointed. It suggests the true meaning of martial arts (specifically referred to as kung fu here) is fighting. This is the origin of martial arts, hence the name, but it is far from the 'true' meaning.

Strictly speaking, kung fu…

If you look up kung fu (功夫) from Chinese to English, you'll find something consistent with the Wikipedia article on Chinese Martial Arts:
In Chinese, kung fu can also be used in contexts completely unrelated to martial arts, and refers colloquially to any individual accomplishment or skill cultivated through long and hard work.[1] Wushu is a more precise term for general martial activities.
Kung fu generally refers to a skill that takes a long time to develop. So, a chef could have excellent kung fu. He'd be a fantastic chef, and perhaps a terrible fighter. Likewise, a dancer could have great kung fu.

The term wushu (武術) means martial arts, literally. However, if you hear someone say they practice Wushu today, it typically means Modern Wushu from China. Modern Wushu evolved from traditional martial arts and is designed for competitions where participants are judged on their ability to do a form. The forms can be extremely gymnastic as well as impractical when it comes to fighting. Essentially, Modern Wushu is a martial arts style that has adopted more gymnastic movements. Not a dancing style that has adopted moves from the martial arts, as the YouTube teacher claims. That doesn't change the fact that Modern Wushu masters train with all their strength and exhaust themselves to the limits of their body and mind, year in and year out. They, without a doubt, train kung fu.

Aside from the technicalities

If I stumbled upon a few silly errors with naming nuances in this teacher's comments, I wouldn't be writing this. These things are trivial, although I would've expected a native speaker of Chinese and a student of martial arts to be familiar with them. The problem lies in the point, what is the real meaning behind martial arts? Forget about what you call it, Karate, Kung Fu, Wushu, Taekwon Do, and so on. They are all different paths to a similar goal.
Asking the 'true' meaning of martial arts is like asking the true meaning of life: the answer is decided by the artist. It could be to fight, or to dance. It could be to keep yourself in shape so that it's easier to meet girls. It could be anything and it wouldn't be wrong. But, I argue there is a deeper meaning that those who train long and hard realize.
When someone speaks the words kung fu, one of the first images that comes to mind is a Shaolin Monk. Despite sparse instances in Chinese history where Shaolin Monks were involved in battles, why else would they devote themselves to martial arts? Why would their training include anything but practical self defense techniques? The quoted teacher above is training and teaching martial arts heavily influenced by Shaolin (including Hung Gar – 洪家拳).

What are our masters teaching us?

The most respected masters I've trained under taught martial arts as a way of life. Self defense was included in some schools more than others, but it was never the primary focus. The truth is, physical self defense is a tiny part of what martial arts really has to offer.
I had a strict Karate instructor and I was fond of him for that reason. He wasn't afraid to use some power when sparring with me, even when I was inexperienced. When asked if he had ever used Karate for self defense, he replied that he had. Two times. And he instantly regretted it afterwards both times.

Imagine if he had trained for no other reason than to develop those skills. He would've had nothing but regret for so much time spent training. That wasn't the case, he continued training after these events. He developed and rose above his former self.
Gichin Funakoshi is known as the "Father of Modern Karate." He wrote his autobiography, Karate-Do: My Way of Life. In it (perhaps in the prologue, I'm not sure) it mentions how he also used Karate for self defense just two times in his life. Just like my aforementioned Karate instructor, he deeply regretted it immediately afterwards.
The list goes on. I would argue one of the major themes behind Jet Li's Fearless is that martial arts are not about fighting.

If you still don't believe me

Traditional martial arts are ambiguous. I trained with a Karate student preparing for a black belt promotional that never thought the basic blocking drills in Karate were anything more than blocks. The entire moves, when executed in full, are actually terrible blocks. But they work great for breaking someone's grip on your arms or body. Now he learned those moves as a white belt and trained for over 4 years, and at a good school. It's not his fault. Martial arts are ambiguous for a reason.
As a teacher, you may have strong morals and principals. The last thing you'd want is for your students to go out and get into fights everywhere. But you want them to learn martial arts and you believe it has something to offer them. By teaching them more ambiguous techniques, you're able to pass on the truly valuable aspects of martial arts while omitting a large portion of the deadly parts.

The point is

The true meaning behind martial arts is not fighting. So what is it?

As silly and cliché as this is, especially when talking about martial arts, it's a fantastic way to represent the true meaning of martial arts. The yin-yang symbol represents balance. Mind and body. Harmony. Training martial arts exercises your body, but not without making you think. Working hard and training kung fu of any kind develops character. It helps us to learn more about ourselves and others. It teaches you discipline and confidence; the very skills you need to be a better member of society. It helps you be more balanced. Balance is the key to a better life, as well as a better society.

The problem is

The world of kung fu and martial arts has too many people who get distracted by other things like fighting and sparring. Sparring is nothing like fighting, for starters. Fighting is a life and death situation, sparring is a game. It can be helpful in training kung fu, but it is not necessary. The world of martial arts needs more teachers that realize this. The alternative would be a loss.

2010年12月9日 星期四

Taiwan, the Cool Place Where an Adult Can be a Kid

I enjoy Taiwan. You rarely see men walking with a swagger, swaying side to side as they lift their head up and puff out their chest. Taiwanese tend not to have this false sense of masculinity.

The locals also seem to lack a few cultural misconceptions about maturity. Men and women show a genuine affection for cute things. Americans get to a certain age where the idea of being cute is seen as childish. But, why? What does it mean to be childish? Does it mean you have to hide what you like so you can fall into the norm? I would think the more childish person is the one afraid to express themselves truthfully.

Cute is an aesthetic. We acknowledge the pretty, bold, beautiful, and sexy. For some reason, however, cute is associated with immaturity. It's for children or irresponsible adults. It's also an insult to most men. You can't be taken seriously if you come off as cute, whereas any other aesthetic is perfectly acceptable.

In Taiwan, a thirty year-old woman may be an avid collector of Hello Kitty. At the same time, she can also be a successful manager at a respectable company. Cute does not equal stupid or immature. Likewise, men might dress in a cute and fashionable way on their way to the office or to head out at night. It doesn't suggest their gay or especially effeminate.

A culture without a false sense of maturity is a culture that encourages people to express themselves more freely. Taiwanese are more able to set their inner child free.

Great! Glad I'm here.

Sadly, Taiwanese children have no chance to let their inner child loose. Children don't just have to go to school during the day; they have to go to cram schools in the evening.

The competition is stiff. Children have to take entrance exams for high school. The quality of a middle school is determined by how many of their students get into good high schools. Kids who get into better high schools are better prepared for the next test they have to take – the college entrance exam. This exam is the sole factor in determining which college students can go to. The kid with the top score get first pick, followed by second and so on. I was surprised to hear a junior high student tell me that he would take a practice entrance exam for high school every single day he went to school.

It's true that the best way to prepare for a test is to practice. If other students are practicing at cram schools in the evening, the only way to keep up is to have yours do the same. Compared to the average US student, Taiwanese have less time to explore social and extracurricular activities. They have less time to think about what they're interested in and what's important to them. They have less time to have fun and be a child.

Now, are Taiwanese more mature because they are more in touch with their inner child? Or are they simply making up for the fact that they didn't have a real chance at a childhood when they deserved it?

2010年9月23日 星期四

Falling into the Forest

I wrote about how it is easier to study a culture through foreign eyes. I also read about this concept in Warren Bennis’s On Becoming a Leader. There is an interesting caveat I forgot to mention. If you truly immerse yourself in a foreign culture, you will find you are not observing anything anymore.

I have spent so much time improving my Chinese and jumping into the culture that I stopped noticing anything about it. I had no foreign friends, outside of work. My day-to-day activities became local; there were no thoughts about why things were different. I stopped analyzing the world I was living in and just lived.

I could no longer see the forest for the trees. I may as well have been living in my old home of upstate New York.

Having some old friends and family visit was helpful. Their culture shock brought me back into perspective, thankfully. It is important to look at the whole picture and examine your life. You do not have to be in a foreign place, it simply forces you to think about things because they are so different.

If you fail to take yourself out of your current perspective and look at the entire forest, you don’t actively live. Instead, you just respond to the stimulus of your environment. You live more like a machine than a person.

2010年4月29日 星期四

好方便!- Perhaps too convenient…

I was in college when I learned the term “方便.” It means convenient. I don’t often use this expression in English so I never paid much attention to it, and wondered if knowing it would even be worth while. It wasn’t until I came to Taiwan that I realized this is a very commonly used phrase. In fact, I heard it every day and began using it more and more. Had my perception changed, did I start to care more about what was convenient to the point where it entered my daily vocabulary?

Convenience is always on the mind of Taiwanese. They have built Taiwan to be a very convenient place. Modernization and innovation have been directed by convenience and, I have to admit, Taiwan is a very easy place to live. So convenient that Taiwan’s East coast feels like one large city. The cities, large and small, are all connected by standard rail lines as well as a high-speed train. You can travel through the major Eastern Taiwanese cities, spread out over a couple hundred miles, more conveniently than you can traverse the two miles from Harvard Business School to Boston University’s West campus. It’s truly convenient, but is there a downside to this?

When things are too convenient and life becomes too easy, we never have to work hard to get what we want. Always having what things at arm’s reach means we never learn to work hard to achieve our goals, or how to deal with things that are not immediately given to us. We become spoiled. Grown adults end up with a lack of appreciation; grown adults start to seem a whole lot more like spoiled children. Too many people expect instant gratification.

Perhaps this is another reason for the rise of the Strawberry Generation in Taiwan?

There are very real consequences to having a more spoiled culture. Taiwan has the lowest birth rates in the world: people do not want to sacrifice their personal freedom and money to raise a family. The majority of Chinese parents I’ve questioned have all said their lives changed for the better, and had much more meaning, after having a child. The selfish desire for freedom and money thus inhibits most people’s chance to experience this kind of true and fulfilling happiness. It’s sad to see wealthy and otherwise successful people sit around and wonder why they “just aren’t happy.”

But the move to modernization and the rising quality of life is not unique to Taiwan. It’s a worldwide thing; it’s what we all work for. I’m an engineer and I’m wondering what the most beneficial thing I can contribute to this world is. Wouldn’t innovation, new designs, things to make our lives easier and at least more enjoyable seem like a good idea? But, if that just spoils future generations, that means I’d be working to cause more harm than good.

2010年4月22日 星期四

Growing Strawberries in Taiwan

A majority of Taiwanese children are spoiled. They audaciously address their parents, in public. Their behavior is unrestricted, running in the street, the supermarket, the mall, and yelling. Taiwanese, from their 20’s through their 80’s have criticized this piece of their culture. “Strawberry Generation,” is how they address the younger generations: they look and taste delicious, but spoil easily.

But why?

Children are spoiled by their parents. We have to rewind time, and look at what Taiwan was like when today’s parents were growing up (post World War II Taiwan).

Following the war, Taiwan was recovering from a taxing Japanese rule. As if the national idea wasn’t already vague, there was a large migration of mainland Chinese with the KMT party and Chiang Kai-Shek. Taiwan was not a developed country and they were not a well established Democratic-Republic. Taiwan would only get around to abolishing martial law in 1987. Its economy was just starting out and, although it would become the successful capitalist economy and tech island that it is today, this seemed far off. People were not able to live the kinds of lives they are able to now.

Children raised at this time had parents who experienced rough times – the Japanese occupation and the World War that brought it to an end. They didn’t have much to give their children. Families had to work hard to get by, most parents had no means of spoiling their children.

These children are the parents of today. They view their children as precious treasures and do for their children what their parents had done for them: give them everything they could. These parents also transformed Taiwan from a cheap labor island in Asia, to a “tech island” and an economic leader on the world stage. They have worked very hard to make all this happen and want to enjoy the fruits of their labor – and share them with their children.

But raising children in a prosperous economy is nothing like raising them during hardship. The parenting practices they learned from their parents were not applicable in this new age. This is parallel with the concept of “New Money.” The result is the “Strawberry Generation.”

What can be done? Even those self-aware parents are spoiling their children. Knowing is not enough.

2010年3月14日 星期日

Small Town, Big Success

I'm reading a great new book, one I recommend to everyone: On Becoming a Leader, by Warren Bennis. I don't recommend this book because we need a world full of leaders, but we should at least be able to recognize the characteristics that distinguish real leaders and true talent.

The book references a survey Victor and Mildred Goertzel conducted on successful people from a wide range of backgrounds. They found out a lot of interesting things, among them were that most successful men and women came from small towns or villages.

This reminded me of an interesting thought I came up with after moving to the city for college. I had made several friends, specifically a couple who had grown up in cities. We talked at great length about the differences in our upbringings.

Children who grow up in small towns or villages, like myself, have to create ways to amuse themselves. We are not faced with the pleasant distractions of city life. My childhood friends and I would often spend hours discussing what few things we could do. We were forced to be creative, and often weren't able to think of anything. We cursed our boredom, but many of us overcame this and found passions worth pursuing.


Bored? Why not make a gigantic snowman?

Conversely, some city friends were "blessed" with many more options. They didn't have the problem of boredom, being let down, or not having anything fun to do. In contrast, they were quite spoiled. They were less likely to use their imaginations, they didn't need to since there was already so much for them.

How does this relate to success? As a "small town boy," I was used to not getting what I wanted. I was also taught, that if I wanted something, like a good time, or a fun day out with my friends, that would require some effort or even creativity on my part. Even with effort, I might fail. So I learned two lessons: how to work hard to get what I want, and how to cope with failure despite earnest efforts.

Conversely, I was surprised to see city friends who, after working hard and coming up short on something would be emotionally devastated, then quit altogether. They had grown up where things they wanted had always been easier to reach. The idea of working hard for something and then failing was not something they were used to. Experiencing failure in college was devastating for them.

Previously, I had thought that the boredom of my small town childhood was a blessing because it enabled me to better enjoy life later on. It helped me deal with the stresses associated with college life at a competitive university. After reading the book, I realize this might actually end up doing more for me in the future. My vision, my determination to be great, and my will power are all things that I can credit to my childhood. They are all things that I will rely on to take me farther in life.

2010年3月11日 星期四

我有話説 - That's right, I've got something to say

I hate silly alarmists. That pretty much means I hate all forms of news. I'm in Taiwan right now. There's always talk of Chinese Vs. Taiwanese politics. A while back I read about a book stating that China was planning on taking over Taiwan by 2012, or something ridiculous like that.

My first comment is, if you're going to make such a bold statement, be careful about dates you put on it. This book, will become a serious joke in 2012 when history proves all predictions wrong. Now, I had a discussion with a few friends about why this would never happen. We're not politicians, we are not even well informed, but we were able to put aside our emotions and look at the situation objectively.

First, take a look at the plan, described by the author of this silly book (I'm not putting the name in this blog, I don't want publicize). China will move to make Taiwan more and more economically dependent on them, and then use this influence to control Taiwanese politics.

My first thought: not a bad plan, but what will happen to my residency status here... I better not get kicked out! I mean China has blocked Taiwan on the world stage several times, and it's basically been an issue of economics. Think about it, if China says to some small African country that you can only do business with us if you don't work with Taiwan... what will that African country say? "No thanks! Taiwan is a tech island, we need them to supply high tech products." I'm leaning more towards, "Well we want all of the cheap food, clothings, and manufactured products that China is producing anyway and we're not so concerned with advanced technology."

So at first glance, this seems like a reasonable idea. But hold on, what about motivation? Why does China want to re-assume full control of Taiwan? Because they're Chinese? Is it like why The US didn't want the South to break off? I mean, we were economically reliant on the South, and they hadn't split apart yet. But China and Taiwan have been ruled under separate law for a long time now. What about that economic desire? Well, if they can already make Taiwan economically dependent on them, to the point where they have enough influence to control their politics, then what do they actually have to gain? The only thing left is pride.

Now, let's take a quick look at the consequences of assimilating Taiwan. On the world stage, there is a delicate balance of power. No one wants to see the US, China... any of the major super powers, no one wants to see them continue to grow. We have a balance right now. China taking over Taiwan, a small democratic island, would not sit well with the other major countries of the world. And why in 2012!? Because of Chinas triumphant return to the world stage, they've been under an immense amount of criticism lately. US reporters are going crazy over in China, making more news than actually reporting.

I hate to read an article and feel the immediate sense of urgency that comes out of it. Feelings of intense anger are stirred up inside of me. Then I take a closer look at the article and realize, more often than not, 90% of the article is speculation pretending to be fact, and dressed in bright red screaming at you, trying to scare you. Why? Well, would you read an article otherwise. We live in a capitalist society, a capitalist world, even. Truth doesn't sell articles, fear does.

This is what China has to deal with. They're an easy target, and will continue to be for the next few years. If they make a move to take over Taiwan now, even if it is through a political strategy, they won't be gaining anything. They'll be giving the world actual news to report. They'll hinder their own reputation and important relations with the other superpowers of the world.

There could only be one reason for doing something like this: world domination. Yea that's right, China wants to take over the entire world - and they'll start with Taiwan. The US and European countries will be upset, but China doesn't care... soon they'll be a part of the Middle Kingdom, too!

--I'm disappointed with the news I read, to a point that it angers me. Not because I see only bad news and think the world is a bad place, but because I'm afraid other people are actually reading and believing these things.